On 19 November 2026, the International Court of Justice delivered its judgement on the case filed by The Gambia alleging that Myanmar violated the Genocide Convention.
Such
allegations are particularly grave, and have been taken most seriously by the
Government of Myanmar. Throughout the seven years since the case was instituted
in November 2019, Myanmar has participated in good faith in the proceedings,
including by complying with the Court’s order to file 13 Provisional Measures
Reports.
The
Judgement of the Court, reached by a majority of 9 to 6 Judges, decided whether
genocide has been committed, which is the merit of the case. This finding comes
as a great disappointment to Myanmar. A joint dissenting opinion of the
Vice-President and five other members of the Court, including the most senior
judges, considered that the Court has departed from its long-standing case law
concerning the standard of proof that must be met in order to establish that
genocide has been committed. Several of the Judges also expressed concerns over
the treatment and weight to be accorded to evidence before the Court.
The
186-page Judgement is complex, and the 17 separate and dissenting opinions,
comprising a further 269 pages, demonstrate the diversity of views among the
Judges.
Allegations
of violations of obligations under the Genocide Convention are a grave crime.
It should be noted that the Judgement of the Court was delivered with
dissenting opinions and was therefore not decided unanimously. The consensus
among the judges and the requirement to establish the facts beyond reasonable
doubt, as the applicable standard of proof under international law, are matters
that must be accorded the utmost importance when adjudicating a case involving
allegations of genocide. The Fact-Finding Mission (FFM) and NGOs in question
did not have expertise, resources and mandates to produce reasonable evidence
to consider in judicial proceedings, and certainly not in judicial proceedings
in which such a high standard of proof applies. The reports of the FFM and NGOs
are merely second-hand descriptions of other information that the Court has not
seen.
During
both written pleadings and oral submissions, Myanmar has presented
comprehensive and compelling evidence along with facts and records to the Court
demonstrating that the allegations by The Gambia as well as the reports
referenced were wrongful assertions far from the real situation, that the
counter-terrorism actions conducted in northern Rakhine State during 2016-2018
were not carried out with genocidal intent but instead were limited in scope
and duration, lasting only a matter of days, and were undertaken in direct
response to widespread terrorist attacks perpetrated by the Arakan Rohingya
Salvation Army (ARSA) and that it was in fact ARSA’s intimidations, attacks,
destructions, killings and acts of terrorism that laid waste to villages and
cities which led to the displacement of natives and Bengalis.
Myanmar
presented that ARSA’s plots to attack the Border police posts and create all
the insurgencies in the Maungtaw, Buthidaung and Rathedaung were to gain
Myanmar’s police and defence services’ response and to draw the attention of
the international community. Myanmar also proved that ARSA is still at large in
the refugee Camps located in Bangladesh. Despite these reality on the ground,
it is to regret to learn the Judgement delivered by the Court doesn’t reflect
the real situation.
Myanmar
will continue the implementation of humanitarian assistance and rehabilitation
for displaced persons in northern Rakhine State in accordance with domestic
laws, international practices, existing bilateral agreements and ongoing
international cooperation programmes, as well as the verification and
repatriation of those currently residing in Bangladesh as and when situations
permit, while upholding the best interest of its people and sovereignty.
The
situation of Northern Rakhine State has complex historical background and
involves ethnic and religious dimensions, and it is essentially an internal
affair of Myanmar. The international community should view the difficulties and
challenges facing Myanmar objectively and play a constructive role in easing
the situation while respecting Myanmar’s sovereignty, independence, and
territorial integrity. The Government of Myanmar will take time to carefully
and thoroughly study the Judgement.
Ministry
of Foreign Affairs
20
November 2026
#TheGlobalNewLightOfMyanmar
No comments:
Post a Comment