By Min Khant
Asuperficial look at the ruling of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) regarding the genocide case, which has been a matter of intense public interest in Myanmar, might lead many to believe that The Gambia secured an outright victory and Myanmar suffered a defeat.
However,
an in-depth analysis of the case revealed that it may be true that while
Myanmar did face setbacks on several points, the outcome is nowhere near an
insurmountable defeat. In fact, some aspects of the ruling work in Myanmar’s
favour.
Believing
in the integrity of the ICJ, Myanmar chose to engage with the court in good
faith to contest The Gambia’s lawsuit. Throughout the seven-year legal
proceeding, Myanmar responsibly complied with the court’s orders and
directives. The Myanmar legal team presented solid legal arguments and evidence
proving that there was no genocidal intent, explaining instead that security
operations were conducted strictly as counter-terrorism measures against the
atrocities committed by the ARSA terrorist group. Had Myanmar chosen not to
appear before the ICJ, the court would have undoubtedly issued a far harsher,
unilateral ruling with a unanimous 15-0 vote.
By
appearing before the court, Myanmar’s counter-arguments and substantial
evidence have now been officially entered into the international legal
database. Without this defence, the international community would have accepted
The Gambia’s allegations as true facts. In this respect, Myanmar secured a gain
amid unfavourable findings.
The
ICJ made 13 operative determinations, on which the 15-judge panel voted
individually. Regarding the court’s Determinations 1 and 2, the court ruled
against Myanmar by a narrow margin of 9-6, finding that genocide was committed
and that Myanmar failed to prevent it.
It
is observed that the Court accepted unverified eyewitness testimonies, inflated
casualty figures and exaggerated accounts, despite the lack of strong evidence
from the Gambia side. The narrow 9-6 vote indicates that Myanmar’s legal
defence was effective. However, it is found that a majority of judges lowered
the high standard of proof traditionally required in such grave cases for
various reasons. Notably, the six judges who voted against issued a joint
declaration strongly criticizing the Court for departing from established legal
standards.
Regarding
the court’s Determination 3 (Incitement to Genocide), Myanmar secured a
decisive 14-1 victory, since the court found that Myanmar did not incite
genocide against the Bengalis through hate speech.
The
court voted 11-4 on Determination 4 (Punishment of Perpetrators) that Myanmar
failed to punish civilian perpetrators. Crucially, however, the ruling
stipulates that Myanmar itself must establish an independent tribunal to
investigate and prosecute these individuals. Unlike previous international
cases where suspects were referred to the International Criminal Court (ICC) or
similar international tribunals, the ICJ did not refer this matter to the ICC,
which should be seen as a major positive outcome for Myanmar.
Regarding
Determination 5 (Domestic Legislation), the court ruled 14-1 that Myanmar
lacked adequate domestic laws to prevent genocide. While Myanmar had previously
amended its Penal Code regarding homicide, the court deemed it insufficient.
This issue can be readily resolved by enacting specific domestic legislation
aimed at preventing genocide.
Regarding
Determination 6 (Cessation of Violations), the court voted 14-1 ordering the
cessation of any genocidal acts. Myanmar is already in full compliance with
this directive, as Provisional Measure Order (PMO) reports were submitted
regularly confirming no ongoing violations since the institution of the
proceedings of the case before the Court.
Determination
7, which was decided by a 13-2 vote, mirrors Determination 4, directing Myanmar
to investigate and prosecute suspects under its own domestic mechanisms.
Determination 8 reiterates the obligation to prevent future violations,
aligning with Determinations 1 and 2.
Determination
9, passed 10-5, calls for rehabilitation programmes. Because the Myanmar government
is already actively implementing such initiatives in cooperation with ASEAN,
certain UN agencies, and neighbouring countries including Bangladesh, China,
and India, this poses no significant hurdle.
Regarding
Determinations 10 and 11, the court ruled 10-5 that Myanmar is obligated to
provide reparations to victims. However, in a major setback to The Gambia’s
expectations, no funds are to be paid to The Gambia. Instead, Myanmar is tasked
with assessing the victims, determining the amount, and managing the
distribution process over two years, subject to final ICJ approval.
Determination
12, which was passed 11-4, concerns the destruction of evidence, and this
finding requires no further specific action from Myanmar. Meanwhile, Myanmar
achieved a unanimous 15-0 victory on Point 13, rejecting all of The Gambia’s
remaining demands, including calls to grant citizenship to the Bengalis and to
officially recognize them as an ethnic group of Myanmar under their proposed
name.
Overall,
the ruling cannot be characterized as a defeat for Myanmar. The Gambia failed
to achieve its primary objectives, such as securing citizenship for the
Bengalis, transferring suspects to the ICC, and extracting exorbitant financial
reparations. Instead, Myanmar retained its sovereign authority to handle these
matters internally.
Had
the government failed to appear before the Court, a unilateral 15-0 ruling
could have concluded the case before the 2025 elections, potentially
threatening the country’s territorial integrity. Successfully averting that
outcome represents a clear gain for the nation.
After
carefully and thoroughly studying the Judgement, the Government of Myanmar,
like any other sovereign nation, will take action based on its own
determination, national interests and realities on the ground, while also
seeking support from major friendly nations on the international stage.
The
international community should also respect Myanmar’s sovereignty,
independence, and territorial integrity, and view the difficulties and
challenges Myanmar is facing objectively and fairly, and constructively
cooperate and participate in improving the situation. The Ministry of Foreign
Affairs has already highlighted in a statement that, given the differences of
opinion among the judges who made the decision and the complex and lengthy
court ruling, the Myanmar government will take time to carefully study it.
In
conclusion, the people of Myanmar have no reason to be overly alarmed by the
ICJ judgement. Only when the government, the Tatmadaw (armed forces), and the
public work hand in hand to safeguard national interests and sovereignty can
the country overcome any obstacle and achieve lasting success.
#TheGlobalNewLightOfMyanmar

No comments:
Post a Comment